August 22, 2006

A Northern Virginia story – How a $1.1 million house sold for $530,000

This is a pretty interesting story – now granted, it’s in Northern Virginia which is not special like the Bay Area, but still… an interesting story: – Housing Slump Proves Painful For Some Owners and Builders
Joan Guth is one homeowner who was taken by surprise. Last September, she put her stately five-bedroom home in Herndon, Va., on the market for about $1.1 million. She was confident she would get something near that price, and planned to use the proceeds to buy a retirement home in Florida. But her home in the Washington suburbs attracted few serious lookers, and in March, she cut her asking price to $899,900. Still there were no takers. Finally, on the advice of her broker, she called in an auction firm, beginning a process that would eventually reveal to her just how weak the Northern Virginia market had become.


Ms. Guth, whose home in Herndon, Va., had failed to attract a buyer after months on the market, eventually turned to Tranzon Fox, an auction firm based in Burke, Va. Ms. Guth had based her initial $1.1 million asking price on a 2005 appraisal of her home, which now appeared far off the mark. She and her family decided they would accept the highest bid of at least $675,000.

Kristin Eddy, a 35-year-old pediatric occupational therapist living in a town home in Reston, Va., had noticed Ms. Guth’s dark-green turreted home with its wraparound verandas while riding her bike along a nearby trail. “I’ve had my eye on that house for a long time — as a dream,” Ms. Eddy says. When it first went on the market, it was far beyond her price range. Then she noticed the sign announcing the auction.


Ms. Eddy figured her chances of winning were near zero. When the auction began, it became clear that there were only two serious bidders. Although Mr. Karbelk tried to stir excitement, the bidding petered out within minutes. Ms. Eddy was the high bidder, at $475,000.

Looking stricken, Ms. Guth and one of her sons huddled with their broker for a few minutes. Then they told the auctioneer they wouldn’t accept the bid, which fell below the stipulated minimum that hadn’t been revealed to bidders. The auction was over.

Ms. Guth said she would move and leave the house empty until she could sell it at a reasonable price. Late that afternoon, Ms. Eddy raised her offer to $525,000. The Guths wavered for two days before agreeing to accept about $530,000. Ms. Eddy is getting a home with five bedrooms, four full bathrooms, a half-acre lot and a three-car garage for about what some people had been paying until recently for town houses in the area.

Ms. Guth has revised her retirement plan. The disappointing auction result made it difficult for her to afford the kind of home she wanted in Florida. She has decided to buy a home in South Hill, a rural area of south-central Virginia where home prices are cheaper than they are in either Florida or the Washington suburbs. She thinks she can find a home there for $175,000 or less.

Click here to post a comment -- Posted by: burbed @ 10:44 pm

No Responses to “A Northern Virginia story – How a $1.1 million house sold for $530,000”

  1. John Says:

    Oh Burbed, you’re so cruel… giving us hope in the bay area that we can find a similar deal 🙁

    Palo Alto for $600k and/or bust!

  2. seamus Says:

    Oh man… There are three houses in my neighborhood listed at over $1M. All are modest homes with modest views. I’m thinking of offering them $530k, see if anyone else wants to go auction against me. From the length of time these homes have been on the market, I’m thinking they’ll be all mine.

  3. Ken Says:

    Oh Burbed, you’re so cruel… giving us hope in the bay area that we can find a similar deal…

    Just wait a year or two.

  4. Brian Says:

    I grew up in Herndon and can imagine few to no houses in that area that would fetch $1.1M.

    I googled “Joan Guth” and found a Herndon listing with an address. I don’t know the exact property offhand, but I know the street and $1.1M is probably a stretch for anything in that neighborhood, which is a combination of modest single family homes, new McMansion types and older Victorian style structures. Whoever got it for $530K definitely got a deal though.

  5. "Jersey Jerry' Foster Says:

    I have spent many nights in that home and must let everyone know that it is the biggest house in Herndon and when built it was a boarding house at the end of the railroad … this home has been completly remodeled w/up scale bathrooms (3 full ‘n 2 half) w/3 very large bedrooms ‘n 4 more good size ones … would make a GREAT B & B w/3 side rap-a-round porch in very nice area of Old Town Herndon … it’s just a BAD market.

Leave a Reply

Please be nice. No name calling, no personal attacks, no racist stuff, no baiting, etc. Let's be nice to each other in the true Bay Area spirit! (Comments may be edited/removed without notice.)