January 13, 2013

San Francisco is the Brooklyn to Silicon Valley’s Unbuilt Manhattan

Discuss.

130112-sfbrooklyn-startrekAs disappointed visitors and new employees discover, Silicon Valley is a dull and ugly landscape of low-rise stucco office parks and immense traffic-clogged boulevards. The fancy restaurants are in strip malls, like you’d find in Arizona or something. There is nothing to do, nowhere to go. Massive arcologies like the new Apple campus are where the tech giants are headed, but until there are living urban neighborhoods connecting these monstrosities, anyone with hopes for a life outside of work will pay a ridiculous premium to live in San Francisco and spend two hours of every day sitting on a bus.

Meanwhile, the areas around and in between the tech giants of Silicon Valley are mostly ready to be razed and rebuilt. There are miles and miles of half-empty retail space, hideous 1970s’ two-story apartment complexes, most of it lacking the basic human infrastructure of public transportation, playgrounds, bicycle and running and walking paths, outdoor cafes and blocks loaded with bars and late-night restaurants. This is where the new metropolis must be built, in this unloved but sunny valley.

And then the new supercity gets linked to San Francisco by an existing boulevard of run-down old malls and decrepit car lots that pours right into the Mission District and downtown SF, 40 miles north. The boulevard is El Camino Real, or California Route 82, the one-time king’s highway that could be a new corridor of high-rise apartments and HQs and restaurants and museums filling in the long gaps between downtown San Jose and Apple/Google/HP/Yahoo/Intel and Stanford University and San Francisco. With local light rail at street level and express trains overhead or underground, the whole route could be lined with native-landscaped sidewalks dotted with pocket parks and filled on both sides with ground-floor retail, farmers markets and nightlife districts around every station. Caltrain already runs just east of Route 82, and BART already reaches south to Millbrae now.

130112-sfbrooklyn-bartconceptThe above is from a piece in The Awl that notes the large number of young, hip techies who may work in Silicon Valley but definitely don’t want to live in a ginormous, boring suburb.  Yes, there are well-paid people out there who don’t want to spend a million dollars for a sixty year old tract house, or even three thousand a month to merely rent one.  So what would you replace the endless clone houses of San Jose with?  Or would you simply raze most of Redwood City and rebuild Manhattan there?

This is also a great time to whip out this map of the region again, to remind everyone what makes The Bay Area So Special.  Pay careful attention to the region along The Street of Kings.

Thanks very much to Apocryphon at MetaFilter for linking to these sites above.

Comments (8) -- Posted by: madhaus @ 5:06 am

8 Responses to “San Francisco is the Brooklyn to Silicon Valley’s Unbuilt Manhattan”

  1. Alex Says:

    Why would anyone want to turn the Bay Area into a cesspool called Manhattan?

    Why would anyone in their right mind want to placate a bunch of entitled, self-serving, pretentious “hipster” Obamabots? We already have enough idiotic, communist Obamabots around here.

  2. Real Estater Says:

    A while back there was an article in the SF Chronicle saying that there is a plan to double the skyline of San Francisco. That’s the only way it would work, to expand upon an existing city. Right now I find very little reason to go to San Francisco. The city has nowhere near the quantity of attractions that exist in Manhattan. To have fun for west coasters, one really has to travel out to the Pacific Rim. Any number of cities there is more dynamic and more fun than SF by order of magnitudes.

  3. Petsmart groomer Says:

    Middle-aged men with kids and living in suburbs don’t see reasons to go to SF. News at 11.

  4. SEA Says:

    “To have fun for west coasters, one really has to travel out to the Pacific Rim.”

    The RBA is very sad.

  5. Alex Says:

    “Hipsters” and Manhattanites lack creativity.

    Plenty of fun to be had on the wrong side of the street. Lots of hookers and blow to go around.

  6. Real Alex Says:

    How about cloning Venice in Redwood City lagoon instead? :P

  7. wave Says:

    San Francisco’s population has become much older and less diverse, probably because of housing costs. It’s almost like a bedroom community now. I don’t see much gain from living there and commuting 2 hours every day.

  8. Divasm Says:

    I don’t understand today’s youth. When I was a Cupertino teen, cruising down El Camino late at night in my 1970 Plymouth Duster blasting Bon Jovi was our social life. What’s the problem??


Leave a Reply

Please be nice. No name calling, no personal attacks, no racist stuff, no baiting, etc. Let's be nice to each other in the true Bay Area spirit! (Comments may be edited/removed without notice.)